surma
d7b78ed0fd
Activation path (review T6R): a broken plugin or a stray file in /plugins blocks no activation; candidates replace their own entries; discovery has a 10 s deadline and its process is stopped after the answer; an unchanged hash keeps plugin.prev.wasm; activations run in their own task; the watcher is not recursive; no duplicate services; rpc.retired waits for live processes of its version; reads and hashes on blocking threads. Guest I/O and per-call paths: a stdin write error is EOF, stdout and stderr are drained before the status; stderr is lossy UTF-8 and goes to the journal from its own reader; compiled components are freed; shutdown starts no new processes; lock queues drop stopping processes; compile before the admission gate; CommandPre per component; core.unlock in order; null errors are successes; the journal thread survives SQLite errors. sausage init builds the agent with cargo.build; sausage without a command creates ./world. The console reads plain lines without a terminal. PROTOCOL.md and DECISIONS.md describe the decided rules. The flake tests the whole workspace and checks the packaged cargo.build.
81 lines
4.1 KiB
Markdown
81 lines
4.1 KiB
Markdown
# Decisions
|
|
|
|
Why Sausage is the way it is. `PROTOCOL.md` and the code own the details.
|
|
When this file disagrees with them, they win.
|
|
|
|
## The shape
|
|
|
|
- **JSON-RPC, not component interfaces.** Every language can read and write
|
|
lines of JSON, and models know JSON-RPC from LSP and MCP. A call has a
|
|
result, like an LLM tool call.
|
|
- **A process per call.** WASI has no threads, so processes give
|
|
parallelism. A new version applies at the next call, and old processes
|
|
retire after a grace period.
|
|
- **Attached by default.** A process does not outlive its caller by
|
|
accident. A long-running process must ask for `detach`.
|
|
- **Services in one file.** Only the core starts and restarts them, so
|
|
upgrades and singletons need no logic in plugins.
|
|
- **Files to inspect, calls to act.** This keeps the core API small, and the
|
|
agent's file tools are enough to explore the world.
|
|
- **The core accepts only `.wasm` files.** It knows no source language.
|
|
`cargo` is one way to get a `.wasm` file.
|
|
- **The world folder is the source of truth.** Copy a plugin folder into
|
|
another world, and it works there.
|
|
- **The agent is a normal plugin.** It can read and upgrade its own source,
|
|
and change how it does inference.
|
|
|
|
## Interfaces
|
|
|
|
- **Generated imports and interface checks, without version numbers.** A
|
|
model that translates a description by hand makes errors. A generator does
|
|
not. The check catches the most common error in a world that changes
|
|
itself: a change to one plugin breaks another one.
|
|
- **A small schema subset.** With Draft 7 and a fixed subset, our own check
|
|
can decide every case. It never has to guess.
|
|
- **Docs are part of the interface.** Other agents work from them, so the
|
|
SDK requires a doc comment on each method, type, and field.
|
|
- **The check covers calls, not state.** Old and new versions share
|
|
`/state`. A plugin keeps its state format compatible, or migrates it in
|
|
`rpc.retired`.
|
|
|
|
## Minimal on purpose
|
|
|
|
The core does only what a plugin cannot do for itself. Everything else can be
|
|
a plugin, or a change that the agent makes to itself.
|
|
|
|
- **No permissions, no limits, no hiding.** Any process can call, upgrade,
|
|
or stop any plugin, read and write every file, and use the network. The
|
|
checks protect against mistakes, not against plugins. Locks are advisory.
|
|
- **Locks are in the core.** A plugin cannot see that another process died,
|
|
so it cannot release that process's lock. The core can.
|
|
- **Our own VFS, in its own crate.** It works on Linux and macOS, it makes
|
|
`/proc` live, and plugin-served files need it later. Mounts now, overlays
|
|
later.
|
|
- **TCP endpoints for now.** They need no host code. VFS pipes can replace
|
|
them later behind the same SDK API.
|
|
- **Simple scheduling for now.** An epoch tick every 10 milliseconds keeps
|
|
the core responsive and makes kills reliable.
|
|
- **The agent is dumb.** It has a short prompt, a few tools, an append-only
|
|
history that it sends in full, and no compaction. When the context is too
|
|
large, it stops sending the oldest turns, so it never gets stuck.
|
|
|
|
## Small choices
|
|
|
|
- **Plain POSIX files.** Programs like `tempfile`, git, and SQLite expect
|
|
normal files. Atomic writes use a temporary file and `rename`.
|
|
- **Tests run under WASI.** `cargo test` on the host cannot find failures
|
|
that occur only in WASI, for example a missing WASI function or a panic at
|
|
start. The test runner uses the same Wasmtime and the same mounts as the
|
|
core.
|
|
- **The SDK is not published.** `cargo` points `sausage-plugin = "0.1"` at
|
|
its own copy, which it also shows in `/plugins/cargo/sdk/`.
|
|
- **Discovery has a deadline of 10 seconds.** It is an internal call of the
|
|
core, not a limit on plugins. Without it, one plugin that does not answer
|
|
would block every activation.
|
|
- **A broken plugin blocks nobody.** A plugin without a document is already
|
|
broken, so the check cannot protect it. The graph shows it as
|
|
"unavailable", and `core.revert` and `force` always work.
|
|
- **`rpc.retired` is best effort.** It does not run if the host stops first.
|
|
A persistent queue of retirements would be more core for a rare case, so a
|
|
new version checks its own migration marker instead.
|